“And
well, I've been thinking things, thinking things that I just hope
aren't true. Like maybe you don't choose punk rock, because punk rock
chooses you."
-from
"Picking Sides" by Wingnut Dishwashers Union
Idolatry is alive and well among the punks. Growing up punk my walls were decorated with posters and pictures of Sid Vicious, Kurt Cobain, Dee Dee Ramone, and countless other dead rock stars. I used to watch SLC Punk, and imagine myself running around Utah and causing chaos, because there wasn't much else to do in my “suburban prison.” The problem is that when you look up to heroin addicts and suicidal psychopaths, who also happen to play guitar, you get a warped view of your place in the world. Drugs and death are glory, and all your energy goes towards them and causing anarchy. You stand in opposition to safety and all forms of responsibility, especially responsibility for your own life, or at least that's what happened to me.
[I walked into Johnny's old apartment. This would be the last time I walked into these white washed walls. The room was lit for a hangover, lights off, shades down. The room was barren save for a coffee table covered in old rigs and dead soldiers and his mattress on the ground with a crumpled blanket near the bottom. Everything else in the apartment was gone. The guitars, books, furniture, video games, computers, all decorated the shelves of pawn shops or second hand stores. Carroll had just been shipped off to jail for the next two years. Ryan laid in a box buried somewhere in Lakeview. All that was left was a coffee table, Johnny, and his mattress.]
"I'll drink myself to death or at least I'll drink myself to sleep. Chain smoke my way through the gaps in between my aspirations and my apathy."
-
from "Whiskey is My Kind of Lullabye" by Johnny Hobo and
the Freight Trains
I actively pursued death for the first two years of high school. A mix of depression and nihilism had made me the perfect storm of a teenage self-casualty. Kurt Cobain ended his suicide note with these words from Neil Young: "It's better to burn out than fade away." If these words are true, as I believed them to be in my youth, then I wasn't just burning out, I was a fucking inferno consuming everything in my path, sparing no values, hopes, or aspirations in my life. I did every and any drug offered to me, and it wasn't uncommon to find me lying passed out on the floor of someone's house, muttering in my sleep. I didn't want to be alive, and I made sure everyone damn well knew it, not only in my actions, but in my words, as I guaranteed everyone within earshot that by the time I was eighteen I would be a corpse. And I lived like that for almost two years.
[I could hear Johnny in the bathroom hacking up violently the entire contents of his stomach. He was dope sick as usual. Suddenly there was a flush, and he exited. Johnny looked half dead already, his eyes were barely open and hollow. He had lost a lot of weight in the last couple months and it showed. A torn and stained G.G. Allen shirt was draped over his body, and his jeans were tied tightly around his waist with a shoelace. His arms were black and blue covered in holes. "Hey kid," he said, now looking at me, "you keep staring at me like that, and I'm gonna start thinking you wanna fuck."]
"I
was so wasted! I was so fucked up! I was so screwed up! I was so
jacked up! I couldn't get any higher than that."
-from
"Wasted," by Circle Jerks
The
first time I got arrested I was sixteen. They almost sent me to a
mental institution to be put on suicide watch. I had been drinking
quite a bit, (my BAL was .28, a little over three times the legal
limit, and upon hearing this I threw my arms in the air and screamed
"HiGH SCOOORE!"), and happened to run my mouth to a cop
about how they might as well shoot me, because I was going to kill
myself that night. Instead of being commited, in no small thanks to
my father, a former cop himself and card caring member of the
Fraternal Order of Police, I just got stuck into therapy for a while,
and grounded for three months. Eight months later, the second time I
was arrested, this time for shop lifting, I got stuck with a $200
fine, a ban from Macy's for two years, and a week's grounding. Two
months after that, the third, and I'm proud to say final, time I was
arrested, there were no consequences. The cops in East Cleveland had
better things to worry about than a few kids getting high on the
street, and my parents had given up.
[Growing
up, Johnny was my hero. He took me under his wing when I was twelve
and he was fourteen, and gave me a burnt copy Black Flag's "Damaged"
one of my favorite albums of all time, a copy of the Communist
Manifesto, and American Gods by Neil Gaiman. However, it wasn't just
the departing of knowledge, but also the departing of substances as
if they were candy. Johnny was a drug addict to his core to be
honest. When he smoked pot, he'd smoke an eighth a day. When he
popped pills, he'd go through a script of eighty oxys in a week.
When he snorted coke, he'd do an eightball in an afternoon. And when
he shot heroin, well, he never came back.]
"Have you ever had a dream that your favorite baby's drowning, and you grab him by his sweater sleeve and pull him up to the ground and you can hear the water slosh inside his tiny gut push his belly up and down, but he can't cough the water up."
-from
"My Mom," by Kimya Dawson
After
the third time I got arrested, my parents sat me down outside. I was
sure that they were going to murder me, after three arrests in barely
a year, but they didn't kill me, or ground me, or do anything really.
We just sat there and talked. They asked me if I was going to drop
out of high school, because it certainly seemed like it. I just sat
there, frozen. Truth be told, I wanted to drop out. I wanted to
never show up to school again, move out, and live out my downward
spiral to “joyful” oblivion and eventually death. Yet, I was
stopped by one thing, my mother's face. Have you ever looked someone
who's heart you broke in the eyes? Was it your own mother? The
woman who raised me, who wanted nothing but the best for me, who had
cradled me in her arms as a baby and imagined what could come of me,
now looked at her son, and her heart shattered. I can't imagine what
was running through her mind, maybe it was memories of carrying her
sixteen-year-old son out of a police station because he couldn't
walk, or the tip from a "concerned friend" that I was
snorting painkillers, or perhaps it was my older cousin and his path
which ended in a Kentucky prison.
"No," I barely murmured, a little shy and a lot choked up, "no, I'm going to graduate."
[Johnny and I sat in his dark apartment. We were drinking Papst Blue Ribbon, and Johnny got ready to push off. A cigarette hung from his lips and flapped as he talked. "So, I'm being evicted." He dumped the last bit of dope from his vial into a spoon. "Like I got til the end tomorrow to move out." He moved his lighter under the spoon, making the dope and water bubble. "Can you believe that shit? I got one day, a single fuckin' day, to move all my earthly belongings outta here." He tore the cotton filter out of his cigarette with his teeth, and placed a bit of it into his concoction. "Like look around, I don't own a lot, but still, fuck!" He placed the needle into the cotton and pulled in the now liquid heroin into his rig. "Like I don't got no where to go anymore! What the fuck am I suppos- hold up." He tied off his arm with a bandanna, and started tapping out a vein. "There it is-anyways like da fuck am I supposed to do?!"]
"No one needs to tell me, how to get (get get) down. But won't someone tell me, how to get back up?"
-from
"First Song," by Ramshakle Glory
A month later, I started my junior year of high school. It wasn't hard to get my shit together, and I quickly brought my grades up from C's and D's to A's and B's simply by doing homework for once. I stopped being constantly on some substance or another, and started to live like I was going to be alive for longer than a few more months. The depression that had launched me on this voyage of self-destruction, however, remained as strong as ever. I was staying alive not for myself, but others. My parents, my friends, my teachers, they're the ones who wanted to see me stay alive and make something of myself, not me. I had to learn to be okay with myself, before anything really changed, and that was much harder than simply getting my life together. Happiness came slowly as I learned not to hate myself. Ironically the self-destruction in response to my depression had only worsened it, but by getting my life together it became easier to live. Over the next few years, I slowly gained control over my depression. It was an uphill battle, and it is something I still struggle with to this day, but eventually, depression no longer controlled my life. It seemed I had finally escaped, but things are rarely that easy.
[He jabbed the syringe into his arm. "Fuuuuuuuuuuuck. This shit...thisssss shhhit..it's the fucking shit hahahaha. But uhhhh what was I saying? heh heh. Oh yeaaa fucking my fucking landlord fuck-face-piece-a-shit-cocksucker is putting me out on the fucking streets! Fucking TOOL OF THE FUCKING BOURGEO-ZEEeeeeeee!" He nodded off for a bit. I shook him, and told him I was going to go. What I didn't tell him, but I couldn't be around this anymore. I couldn't see him like this. "Huh? What? Oh, yea-yea-yea-yeah for sure my dude...Wait kid, before...before..." His eyes closed, his body went limp, and then he snapped backlike a rubber band. "ba-FOre you go can I ask you for aaaa...ummm a fucking what's it fuckin' called...Shit, wait." He sipped his beer, stood up, and tried to straighten himself out. “A fucking favor? That's the fucking word. God damn this shit is something fuckin' else. Anyways can I get like twenty bucks? Just so I can get some food tomorrow, you know?" I knew he wasn't going to buy food with it, but I gave it to him anyways. I felt compelled to give him something, because I had the feeling that I wouldn't get another chance. "Thank you dude! Hahahaha fuck yeah. I'm gonna eat tomorrow heh heh heh. Shit..." He nodded off, and I never saw him again.]
"I went to about five funerals this year, and I felt so empty that I couldn't even shed a tear."
-from
"5 Funerals," by Bomb the Music Industry!
My cumulative GPA at the end of high school was a 2.82, despite not falling below a 3.3 after my sophomore year. It kept me out of a lot of colleges, and prevented me from getting quite a few scholarships here at OU. And despite my life changes, most of my friends I had made over the years had not ended up the same. Over the next few years eight of my friends died, a few were incarcerated, and countless others dropped out, became junkies, or worse. The causes of death were as expected, mostly suicides and ODs. It's weird, but after the first two or three people died, I started to just expect it. I contemplated which of my friend's funerals I would be attending next. Death became an empty word, simply meaning that I wouldn't see someone again, usually after they had already fallen off the face of the earth. It's hard to call it a tragedy when someone who only sits in their basement and shoots dope dies, because it's just so predictable and you come to expect it. And sometimes I think that they were already dead, just waiting for their heart to stop.
[A couple weeks later, I got a phone call from a mutual friend of Johnny and me. "Yo David, it's Mikey. What's up mah dude? Yeah, no shit? Cool, cool, but I got some bad news. You hear Johnny got picked up a few days ago? Nah? He got busted with a bit of dope. A half g I think. Well yesterday me and Carroll's mom we went up, and bailed him out, and he was sober. Yeah for real. I know it's been like two years since I saw him not all doped out. Anyways Carroll's mom keeps asking him to move into her house and get sober, like permanently, and Johnny's just like 'Maybe later, I got some shit to do.' Then today...they found him. He's-he's gone man. He...uh...he slit his wrists behind a CVS. Yeah, I think everyone kinda did. For sure it's this Thursday. Yeah I think his mom and dad are coming too."]
"If
you don't die young, you're going to live too long"
-from
"Bonus Oceans," by Jeff Rosenstock.
The question became not why did so-and-so die, but rather why did I survive. Why is it that people, some of whom were more cautious and sober than me back in the day, end up where they did when I escaped almost unscathed? Why am I alive, and he isn't? The simple answer, it seems, would be that I turned around when they didn't, but that doesn't give me any relief. Sometimes, I feel as if I shouldn't have been able to turn around, as if I should be buried with everyone else. It would be so much easier to have died than to have to watch everyone else die. That's not to say I wish I was dead, but simply that dying, is much easier than staying live. But I didn't choose the easy way, and I worked through my issues, and am now almost a productive, if incredibly radical, member of society.
Kurt Cobain ended his suicide note with these words from Neil Young: "It's better to burn out than fade away." I ended up not burning out, and I just might have faded away, but I like it better this way.
Dave,
ReplyDeleteThis is an intense essay. It's sad and there aren't really any false notes. And because it's about such an emotional topic, it's hard to offer advice, but here goes, prefaced by praise.
First, the structure is immaculate. The fact that you're able to mix tones and scenes with this kind of balance while including all of the quotations is a testament to the care you put into the piece. You have a knack here. This is your central story, it seems to me, and you knew just how to braid the essay. My guess is you've worked on this in a number of drafts, perhaps honing over months or years. That shows. If this was a two hour schpiel some night, well, color me incorrect, and color me impressed by your Kerouackian talent, but I'm thinking this is more than that.
Second, the frankness with which you speak keeps me reading. And the details you include--lingo, setting-description, mood-shifting pathos with your mom, discussion of your own lapses--this is all working.
I also like how you've included the undercurrent from punk. Here is where the suggestions start. So, I'm thinking punk music and punk culture is an ingredient that actually falls away in this essay. You begin with it and kind of end with it, but the quotes suggest that it's something that brought you and Johnny together, something that hurt you and healed you. So, could you include some details from punk music in some of the sections?
Secondly, this is a grief essay, and, as usual, we want to feel not just the loss of the writer, but what/who has been lost. So, as much as this is hard to suggest, I think you need to show us more of Johnny. I'm even leaning toward saying that healthy-Johnny, if you knew such a person, could be a third braid here. As we see him, he's charming in a certain kind of way that I think you recognize, but it's hard for us to see his best-friend qualities. So, what made him so attractive? Can we get physical description, sound of voice, small bits of charm, or shared interests, sense of humor, sense of shared pain, camaraderie?
Lastly, you touch on depression tenderly. And you mention your own fascination with death. Is it possible to address whether there are root causes for the overwhelming emotions? What started you down that path, and what inner-whatever allowed you to pull out of it where others couldn't? On that point, I sense that you want to write more about survivor's guilt, since that is the title and the main idea of the last section; can this be a topic that gets introduced a little bit earlier? I don't yet feel the searing pain of survivor's guilt I'm assuming you want to get out into the light.
I'm really impressed with this. You have a nothing-to-lose quality as a writer that will serve you well. I think you'd like Mary Karr. You might want to look into her. Also, check out _Another Bullshit Night in Suck City_, by Nick Flynn. An even more intense read would be _Closer to the Knives_, by David Wojnarowicz.
Good stuff Dave. Keep at this. I think more development of this essay could lead to publication. We can talk more if you want.
Dave
David, this was so... terrifying, inevitable, enveloping, painful, I don't know, it was just so much. I'm genuinely very amazed, not because I'm surprised you can produce work like this, but because you're willing to share it and tell it so intimately. This is the opposite of relatable to me; it's unimaginable. But that's not to say it's a bad quality, because this is what made it so striking. You apologize for it in the beginning, but I wish you didn't. As the reader, you make me want to thank you, not demand apologies, because I feel like I've been invited into this story that is so obviously critical to what's inside you. You take the fear of intimacy and smack it in the face. Dave described your writing as 'tender,' and I agree entirely. Reading your gentle, sad language intensifies the violence and horror of what you're actually saying. Honestly, wow. I wish I could italicize 'wow.'
ReplyDeleteDave said something about keeping the theme of punk music stronger through the middle of your essay, which I agree with. Only partly though, because it's not that I personally found your quotes weakening to the story. I found them stirring, especially the mother one.
My one issue is with your title. Survivor's Guilt. I don't really see any guilt in this, at least not in relation to Johnny or your other friends who passed. (I'm sorry.) You seem to have pride in your survival, not guilt. I saw guilt when it came to your mother, which I think you conveyed nicely. This is just a small thing, but perhaps something to think about if you were trying to really highlight your guilt about their deaths.
Really, I am so floored by this. I was going to read everyone's blogs tonight, but I think I'll stop with this for now; you've gotten too deep into my head with this to just move on.
Well, you convinced me to remove the apology at the beginning. I just have this terrible habit of apologizing for everything, but I definitely agree it hurt the tone of the piece. Thanks
DeleteI have that habit too, I apologize for way too much. It makes real sorries less sincere I think, when we overuse it for little things. Not that I found yours in this case insincere, but just unworthy of what you go on to say.
DeleteYour last paragraph was stunning. I actually got the chills when I read it because I felt like it was so simple and yet so difficult for you to finally reach the conclusion that you did. I think it tied everything up really well. Another part of the essay I admired was the structure. I think that switching from Johnny to quote to your story was really smart, and it kept each story from becoming too overwhelming. That is important in a piece like this where you put everything out there and it's just really intense. I admire that greatly. You have a way of just going full-out, smartly. I wondered what Johnny was like before he was addicted, though. Or was there a time when you knew him as anything other than someone who did drugs? You say that he was your hero very close to the top of the piece, but in the same breath you equate him with drugs. So I guess my real question here is how can you tell us if you had any other memories of him? Maybe you don't, and that's fine. If you do, I think it'd be beneficial to show a little bit of that. Really excellent piece.
ReplyDeleteWell I'm late to comment here and I don't know what I can say that hasn't already been said, but I will join everyone else in praising this. I loved your short, hilarious essay about Punk definitions, but this is an even more impressive alternate take on punk culture that gets into the dark side and also offers some very real descriptions of your life and your friend's life.
ReplyDeleteI don't know what recommendations to make. I guess I would just say that this is a big subject and obviously one very important to you, so you could certainly dwell on it longer. It's great as it is, so I don't think it NEEDS to be longer, but I think it certainly COULD be longer if you wanted it to be.
"And sometimes I think that they were already dead, just waiting for their heart to stop" is a very well-written line.